Show summary Hide summary
- Women in leadership roles: different behavior, same temptations
- Conflict, force and the gendered lens on leadership
- Show business: a long history of exploitation and the limits of role reversal
- Where women dominate roles: casting, empathy and workplace safety
- Abuse across professions: medicine, education and music
- Comedy, gossip and the code of silence
- Why replacing men with women isn’t a magic fix
- Personal myth, media myths and the Georgian judge tale
When I was a teen, my father — an ardent believer in Soviet idealism — used to tell me strange tales I couldn’t verify without the internet. He described metro stations like ornate palaces and, more oddly, claimed that in Georgia only post-menopausal women were appointed judges because they’d supposedly be more dispassionate. That last story stuck with me as a curious example of how myths about gender and authority travel.
Lately, as scandals in the worlds of politics, international organizations and entertainment keep surfacing, I’ve found myself wondering whether more women in charge would improve things — especially in industries notorious for predatory behavior. The short answer is complicated: women often act differently in positions of power, but swapping leadership gender won’t automatically remove abuse, hypocrisy or the hunger for dominance.
Women in leadership roles: different behavior, same temptations
Women often bring different social expectations and interpersonal skills into leadership roles, and in many contexts that can translate to fewer predatory behaviors toward vulnerable people. Yet history and contemporary events remind us that power corrupts across genders.
The Growing Demand for Data-Driven Decision Making in Silicon Valley
He quit, ran out of money, and begged to come back — here’s how his boss reacted
Several prominent cases involving senior officials at international institutions highlight this nuance. In recent years, high-ranking men at global organizations have faced allegations of sexual misconduct or harassment, prompting resignations and investigations. At the same time, there have been far fewer high-profile cases where female leaders were accused of the same pattern of exploiting younger or subordinate people — not because women are incapable of misconduct, but because the structural and sexual dynamics differ.
Examples that have shaken public confidence include allegations against senior figures at institutions such as:
- International health and humanitarian agencies where senior male managers were accused of sexual misconduct or harassment;
- Charity and advocacy organizations where high-profile resignations followed press reports of alleged inappropriate behavior;
- National and international leaders whose reputations were marred by accusations, even when legal outcomes varied.
These episodes show that abuse often flows from institutional power and opportunity, not simply from an individual’s sex.

Conflict, force and the gendered lens on leadership
Romanticized ideas about female leadership — the notion that women would always choose peace over war — have been popular in some circles. Yet both historical examples and academic research complicate that narrative.
Female leaders from Elizabeth I to Indira Gandhi and Margaret Thatcher did not shy away from confrontation when they judged it necessary. Academic work examining military disputes suggests a pattern: women heads of state may be perceived as less credible in the moment of crisis, prompting them to use force more readily to signal resolve. One analysis covering leaders from 1980 to 2010 found that women were more likely than men to face resistance to their threats and consequently more likely to escalate in order to be taken seriously.
That finding underscores a harsher reality: gendered expectations can force women in power into more aggressive postures, not less. In other words, simply increasing the number of women in top posts won’t guarantee a gentler global order if the underlying dynamics reward displays of uncompromising strength.
Show business: a long history of exploitation and the limits of role reversal
If politics is sometimes called show business for the plain people, the entertainment industry itself wears its power imbalances on its sleeve. For decades, the so-called casting couch — older, influential men exploiting younger performers — was an open secret. The #MeToo era exposed many of these dynamics in painful detail.
High-profile cases changed public perceptions:
- Powerful producers and executives accused of using casting as leverage to demand sexual favors;
- Actors and staffers who reported coercion or harassment, often at great personal cost;
- Occasional, less-publicized allegations of women allegedly abusing power in sexual situations — far fewer in number, and frequently framed differently by society and the media.
The entertainment sector’s structural vulnerabilities — youth, transient careers, gatekeepers with huge influence — make it especially toxic for those without power, regardless of which sex occupies the top roles.
There are isolated cases of alleged sexual misconduct by women toward younger men in the industry, but they are comparatively rare and often received differently in public discourse. The asymmetry stems partly from cultural scripts: older men preying on young women fit a grim, recurring pattern linked to societal tolerance and the commercialization of female youth.

Where women dominate roles: casting, empathy and workplace safety
Some parts of the film business today have more women in key roles than decades ago — casting directors being a notable example. Estimates show that a large majority of casting professionals are female. The usual explanation cites qualities like empathy and the ability to coach actors, but there’s a more blunt practical advantage: fewer reports of coercive sexual demands in castingrooms where women hold decision-making power.
This does not mean that female-dominated departments are immune from misconduct, but it does suggest that gendered workplace cultures influence who gets exploited and how.
Abuse across professions: medicine, education and music
Sexual misconduct is not limited to entertainment. Surveys and studies show troubling trends across professions:
- Medical environments where hierarchical structures and private spaces can enable abuse — some reports indicate significant numbers of women in surgery reporting harassment from colleagues;
- Educational settings where teacher-student sexual relationships occur in both genders but are often framed differently in public debate;
- Pop culture, where male artists have a documented history of pursuing underage fans and collaborators, fueling a pattern of predation that is easier to spot and more frequently prosecuted in public opinion.
Cultural narratives play a strong role here. Songs, stories and public commentary shape what kinds of relationships are normalized or condemned. For example, popular entertainment has rarely centered on the trope of older women seducing teenage boys in the same sensational way as older men preying on girls, and when it does occur it often gets treated differently.
Comedy, gossip and the code of silence
Comedy has long been a scene where male dominance shows through — stand-ups boast about conquests; the industry valorizes edgy masculinity. Yet recent years have produced women comedians who’ve called out toxic backstage cultures, sometimes at professional risk. The dynamic matters because humor can both expose and legitimize predatory or misogynistic behavior.
One notable example is a female comic who publicly challenged a closed, male-dominated circle of performers and survived professional backlash. That moment illustrated two things:
- Women who expose misconduct often face ostracism;
- Industry cultures reward silence, especially when the powerful are entertaining and profitable.
Challenging the “boys’ club” requires both structural change and individuals willing to risk careers to speak up.
Why replacing men with women isn’t a magic fix
Observers who argue that simply putting women in charge would make institutions kinder or safer oversimplify the issue. Power dynamics — not just gender — shape behavior. When women gain authority within existing systems that valorize dominance, they can replicate the same patterns of aggression and abuse to achieve or maintain status.
A few points to consider:
- Motivation and opportunity matter: people in positions with access to vulnerable individuals are the ones who perpetrate abuse;
- Social conditioning shapes how desire and dominance are expressed across genders;
- Institutional accountability, transparency and cultural norms are critical levers for reducing misconduct — regardless of the leader’s sex.
Some commentators note that many women are less likely to pursue sexual control over subordinates or teenagers, partly because female sexuality is often socially shaped around being desired and relational communication. This may reduce certain types of predation, but it doesn’t eliminate the capacity for women to wield power harshly.
Personal myth, media myths and the Georgian judge tale
Curiosity led me back to that odd childhood memory about Georgian judges — and a quick search suggests my father likely invented that rule. He was generous with tall tales. Still, the anecdote serves as a metaphor: myths about who can be trusted with authority—whether because of sex, age or temperament—tend to persist long after the facts are checked.
In the same way, media narratives about sex, power and celebrity often flatten complexity into a single storyline: men are predators, women are victims or vice versa. Reality is messier. Power enables bad behavior; gender shapes its forms.
Julie Burchill writes a column for spiked. Follow her Substack, “Notes from the Naughty Step,” for more commentary on culture and politics.
You might also like:
- Love Island USA women performing for men who don’t respect them sparks backlash
- Afghan sex offenders: what communities and policymakers need to know
- Andy Burnham’s phony feminism under scrutiny
- Erika Alexander on joy, Maxine Shaw and life after Living Single
- Bridgerton gender swap: Masali Baduza and Hannah Dodd respond

Robert Johnson is a dedicated columnist focusing on political and social debates. With twelve years in editorial writing, he provides nuanced, well‑argued perspectives. His commentaries invite you to form your own views and engage in critical issues.
