Show summary Hide summary
- My Life with the Walter Boys — Ranch romance and brotherly drama (Netflix)
- XO, Kitty — K‑drama energy with romantic comedy roots (Netflix)
- Outer Banks — Beachy thrills and high-stakes adventure (Netflix)
- One Tree Hill — Classic teen drama with brotherly rivalry (HBO Max)
- Heartstopper — Gentle LGBTQ+ romance adapted from a beloved graphic novel (Netflix)
- Dawson’s Creek — The blueprint for modern teen love triangles (Hulu)
- We Were Liars — A modern mystery with unsettling seaside secrets (Prime Video)
- One Day — A decade-spanning romance built on one-day snapshots (Netflix)
- Never Have I Ever — High-energy coming-of-age comedy with messy love (Netflix)
Missing the warmth of Cousins Beach and the tangled feelings between Belly and the Fisher brothers? You’re not alone. With The Summer I Turned Pretty wrapped and a movie on the horizon, plenty of viewers are hunting for their next binge — something that captures that heady mix of summer atmosphere, complicated romance, and YA emotion.
Below are nine TV picks that deliver similar vibes: from book-to-screen romances and sibling love triangles to seaside mysteries and coming-of-age comedies. Each pick includes what makes it a good follow-up and where you can stream it right now.
My Life with the Walter Boys — Ranch romance and brotherly drama (Netflix)
The Growing Demand for Data-Driven Decision Making in Silicon Valley
He quit, ran out of money, and begged to come back — here’s how his boss reacted
Think The Summer I Turned Pretty but with cowboy boots and open fields. Netflix’s adaptation of Ali Novak’s Wattpad hit follows Jackie, a teenager who moves to a Colorado ranch after losing her parents and finds herself torn between two brothers in a sprawling family. Expect familiar teenage angst, messy feelings, and plenty of small-town tension.
Why it resonates with TSITP fans
- Love triangle centered around two brothers
- YA novel source material that leans into emotional melodrama
- Strong family dynamics and rural setting that replace beachside nostalgia
Where to watch: Netflix
XO, Kitty — K‑drama energy with romantic comedy roots (Netflix)
From Jenny Han, the creator behind The Summer I Turned Pretty, comes a spin-off that takes Lara Jean’s younger sister to Seoul. XO, Kitty blends teen romance and cultural curiosity with the light, heartfelt tone fans loved in To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before. It’s breezy, romantic, and full of boarding-school drama.
What makes it a good follow-up
- Familiar teen-romcom DNA with a fresh, international setting
- Warm, character-driven storytelling and romantic hijinks
- Short, binge-friendly episodes
Where to watch: Netflix
Outer Banks — Beachy thrills and high-stakes adventure (Netflix)
If you miss coastal escapism but want something more action-packed, Outer Banks delivers. The show follows a tight-knit group of teens in North Carolina pursuing a treasure tied to one of their missing fathers. It’s sun-soaked, dangerous, and loaded with cliffhangers — a different flavor of youth drama that still scratches the beachy itch.
Elements fans of TSITP will enjoy
- Summer setting and strong friendship dynamics
- Romantic subplots woven into a bigger mystery
- High-energy pacing and serialized suspense
Where to watch: Netflix
One Tree Hill — Classic teen drama with brotherly rivalry (HBO Max)
For viewers who want a deeper dive into the long-form, melodramatic teen saga, One Tree Hill is a generational favorite. The series spotlights half-brothers Lucas and Nathan as they battle on the basketball court and fall for the same girl. If you appreciate emotional cliffhangers, intense love triangles, and character growth over multiple seasons, this is a must-watch.
Why longtime drama fans recommend it
- Iconic love triangles and emotionally charged storytelling
- Extended character arcs that reward long-term viewers
- Memorable soundtrack and teen-angst staples
Where to watch: HBO Max
Heartstopper — Gentle LGBTQ+ romance adapted from a beloved graphic novel (Netflix)
Heartstopper arrived as a tender, true-to-the-page adaptation about the shy Charlie and the athletic Nick discovering each other. It emphasizes emotional honesty, small moments, and the beauty of slow-burn connection. Like TSITP, it’s rooted in YA source material and aims straight for the heart.
Highlights for TSITP viewers
- Book-to-screen authenticity and careful character work
- Warm, hopeful tone with memorable chemistry
- Plans to wrap the story with a finale film, echoing TSITP’s feature approach
Where to watch: Netflix
Dawson’s Creek — The blueprint for modern teen love triangles (Hulu)
Often cited as the template for many shows that followed, Dawson’s Creek centers on Dawson, Joey, and Pacey and the complicated feelings among them. Its dialogue-heavy, introspective style and emphasis on romantic entanglement make it a natural pick for anyone comparing TSITP’s tangled relationships to earlier teen TV.
What to expect
- Classic “will they, won’t they” dynamics and intense emotional beats
- Strong focus on friendship, identity, and coming-of-age crises
- Plenty of dramatic twists that shaped the teen-drama genre
Where to watch: Hulu
We Were Liars — A modern mystery with unsettling seaside secrets (Prime Video)
Prime Video’s adaptation of the bestseller leans into psychological suspense. The series follows Cadence as she tries to reconstruct a summer she can’t remember, revealing a wealthy family’s secrets along the way. It’s darker than TSITP but shares the island/seasonal setting and the way a single summer can change everything.
Why fans might gravitate toward it
- Summer-island atmosphere with a mystery at its core
- Book adaptation that rewards close attention and speculation
- Emotionally intense storytelling with twists
Where to watch: Prime Video
One Day — A decade-spanning romance built on one-day snapshots (Netflix)
For viewers who want long-term slow-burn romance rather than a summer fling, One Day tracks the relationship between two characters over 14 years, revisiting them on the same date each year. The structure amplifies longing, missed opportunities, and the small choices that compound into heartbreak or happiness.
How it connects to TSITP themes
- Extended timeline that examines evolving relationships
- Romantic tension and the agony of near-misses
- Emotional payoff that can swing from satisfying to wrenching
Where to watch: Netflix
Never Have I Ever — High-energy coming-of-age comedy with messy love (Netflix)
Mindy Kaling’s hit brings humor and heart to the teen-romance formula. Devi Vishwakumar navigates grief, cultural expectations, and two very different romantic interests, creating a storyline about growth and awkward, earnest love that echoes the emotional core of Belly’s journey.
Reasons TSITP fans often enjoy it
- Blend of comedy and sincere coming-of-age moments
- Complicated romantic choices and chemistry-driven rivalries
- Relatable family pressures and identity exploration
Where to watch: Netflix
You might also like:
- Netflix January: 6 new movies and shows to watch
- Netflix movies and TV shows in June: 6 new releases to watch
- Every Year After on Amazon Prime Video: everything we know
- Netflix July releases: 6 movies and TV shows to watch
- Netflix Christmas movies: 7 holiday gems to stream now
David Miller is an entertainment expert with a passion for film, music, and series. With eight years in cultural criticism, he takes you behind the scenes of productions and studios. His energetic style guides you to the next big releases and trending sensations.
Man, if youre into that summer romance vibe, check out The Kissing Booth series on Netflix. Its got that sweet, cheesy goodness that fans of The Summer I Turned Pretty dig. Get ready for some drama and swoony moments!
Oh, if youre into that whole love-in-the-summer vibe, try My First First Love on Netflix! Its got that same heart-tugging drama and summer feels. Perfect for when youre craving more of that bittersweet romance fix.
I remember binging The Summer I Turned Pretty in one weekend! For more drama and romance vibes, try To All the Boys Ive Loved Before. Its got the heartwarming feels and teen angst we all love. Cheers to more cozy Netflix nights!
As a hopeless romantic, Id suggest diving into My Holo Love for a sci-fi twist on love. If youre into sibling dynamics, Gilmore Girls serves up a heartwarming mix. Both are like a cozy blanket on a rainy day.
Oh, mate, let me tell you, My Holo Love is like that warm hug you never knew you needed on a gloomy day. But Gilmore Girls? Its like a big ol cup of hot cocoa, cozy and comforting. Both are like a snug blanket, just depends on what vibe youre feeling, innit? Whats your pick for a rainy day binge, then?
Man, if you dig that summer vibe with a side of drama, check out The Fosters. Its got family shenanigans, romance twists, and all the feels. Perfect for those missing The Summer I Turned Pretty vibes.
I remember binge-watching The Summer I Turned Pretty till 3 AM! If youre into sibling dynamics and teenage romance, My Life with the Walter Boys on Netflix might hit the spot. Its like a ranch with a side of drama!
As a rom-com addict, Im all about those sweet summer vibes. Shows like The Summer I Turned Pretty? Bring on the beachy drama! Cant get enough of that swoon-worthy tension and heartfelt moments. Hit me with more, please!