Show summary Hide summary
Aaron Judge launched a heater into the left-field seats that felt almost impossible, and the New York Yankees pulled off a comeback nobody else had managed against the Toronto Blue Jays all season. The crowd at Yankee Stadium exploded as New York erased a five-run deficit to win Game 3, keeping their postseason hopes alive.
Despite still trailing in the American League Division Series, the Yankees leave Game 3 having flipped momentum. Judge’s huge swing, plus timely hitting and steady relief work, gave New York a 9-6 victory that suddenly makes this short series far more dangerous for the favored Blue Jays.
Judge’s jaw-dropping homer and the at-bat that changed everything
The Growing Demand for Data-Driven Decision Making in Silicon Valley
He quit, ran out of money, and begged to come back — here’s how his boss reacted
The turning point came in the fourth inning when Judge stepped to the plate with two runners on and New York down 6-3. After fouling off a 100-mph fastball for strike two, he hammered the next offering—another near-100-mph heater that came in tight and up—sending it off the left-field pole. The long drive produced a loud reaction from the stands and put the Yankees back within reach.
That swing was historic by the numbers. According to pitch-tracking records, no one in the tracking era (since 2008) had homered on a pitch that hard from that inside location. Judge’s postseason resume expanded as well: he finished the night 3-for-4 and has been scorching in October, elevating his overall playoff batting line.
Key plays and how New York completed the comeback
- Judge’s RBI double: Beyond the homer, he added a run-scoring double and drew an intentional walk later, providing consistent offense throughout the night.
- Jazz Chisholm’s go-ahead shot: Chisholm unloaded a tie-breaking solo homer that put the Yankees on top for good, a swing that energized both the dugout and the bullpen.
- Defensive hustle: Judge’s sprawling catch in right on Anthony Santander halted a Blue Jays rally and preserved New York’s momentum.
- Relief dominance: A bullpen unit that combined for 6 2/3 scoreless innings—capped by right-hander David Bednar—shut down Toronto after the early lead evaporated.
Players to watch in the box score
- Aaron Judge — 3-for-4 night with a three-run homer, an RBI double and an intentional walk; continued postseason success.
- Jazz Chisholm — delivered the clutch homer that flipped the game in the sixth inning.
- Blue Jays offense — early fireworks, including a long two-run shot from Vladimir Guerrero Jr., but stalled after the third inning.
Why this comeback matters: the statistical and psychological swing
Before Tuesday’s game, Toronto had been perfect when leading by five runs or more during the calendar stretch, a dominant 39-0 mark including postseason play. The Yankees, conversely, had almost no history of rallying from that deficit. New York’s comeback is more than a single tally in the win column; it injects doubt into Toronto’s strategy and gives the Yankees a renewed edge in a tight series.
For the Blue Jays, the loss highlighted several concerns: shaky starting pitching availability, a defensive lapse or two, and an inability to manufacture offense after the opening frames. Combined, those issues made Tuesday’s win for New York feel like a momentum grab as much as a game result.
Pitching plans, rest, and what to expect next in the ALDS
Game 4 is set for Wednesday night in the Bronx, and New York will turn to rookie right-hander Cam Schlitter. Schlitter’s recent outing — eight scoreless innings with 12 strikeouts to wrap up the Wild Card series — makes him an intriguing option with a chance to keep the Yankees alive.
Toronto’s staff plans are less straightforward. Management has hinted at a bullpen approach for Game 4, but several variables remain:
- Kevin Gausman could be asked to pitch on short rest, creating a high-leverage decision for the Blue Jays.
- If the series returns to Toronto for a Game 5, rookie Trey Yesavage would be available on more conventional rest, fresh off a dominant performance against New York.
- Using a bullpen game now might preserve starters for later, but it also risks handing the Yankees more favorable matchups down the stretch.
Scenarios and storylines to monitor as the series shifts
- If New York evens the series: The psychological lift of overcoming a five-run hole could carry into a decisive Game 5, forcing the Jays to rely on rotation depth and bullpen management.
- If Toronto bounces back: The club still has the advantage of a rested rotation at home and can close out the series with a strong bullpen outing.
- Managerial chess match: Pitching choices—short rest starts, bullpen deployment and matchups—will likely determine the next outcome more than raw offense.
You might also like:
- Yankees facing ALDS elimination: can Boone’s unconventional plan spark a comeback?
- Yankees are World Series favorites even without Aaron Judge
- Blue Jays’ historic grand slam leads to 11-4 game 1 win over Dodgers
- Mariners’ game 6 meltdown delays World Series dream for Seattle
- Blue Jays rookie faces biggest test in game 5 of World Series vs Dodgers
John Davis is a sports journalist focused on the NBA, NFL, and major global championships. With seven years of live coverage, he breaks down performances and key strategies. His expertise gives you a clear view of every game and its impact.
Man, that Judge homer was like a shot of adrenaline! The Yankees were on the ropes, but he just had to go and make history. Cant deny the guys got clutch in his DNA. Lets see if they can keep the momentum rolling!
Man, that homer from Aaron Judge was like a bolt outta the blue! The Yanks dodging elimination got me on the edge of my seat. Baseballs a wild ride, aint it? Cant wait to see whats next!
Man, that homer from Judge was like a bolt outta the sky! The Yanks really got my heart racing. Baseballs a rollercoaster, huh? Cant predict a damn thing. Just when you think its over, boom! Excitement all over again. Whos your money on for the next game?
Man, Judges homer was like a shot of adrenaline! Reminds me of those epic baseball moments that keep you on the edge of your seat. Love seeing players step up when it counts. Lets go Yankees!
Oh man, that homer by Judge was straight fire! Totally had me on the edge of my seat, just like those nail-biting baseball moments that give you the chills. Its those clutch plays that make the game so addictive, right? Lets go Yankees!
Man, that Judge homer felt like a lightning bolt striking the stadium! Got me off the couch, screaming at the TV. Yankees dodged a bullet, but can they keep this momentum? Gonna be wild!
Dang, that Judge homer was like a shot of adrenaline, man! Had me jumping off the couch, yelling at the screen too! Yankees definitely dodged a bullet there, huh? But can they ride this wave? Gonna be a wild ride for sure!
Man, that Judge homer was like a shot of adrenaline! Reminded me of that time I hit a home run in Little League. The Yanks really turned it around. Guess theyre not ready to go home just yet.
Man, Judge really turned the heat up with that homer! It’s like watching history in the making. The Yankees needed that spark, and boy, did he deliver. Let’s see if they can keep riding this wave of momentum!
Man, Judges homer was like a shot of espresso in a boring meeting. Suddenly, BAM, everyones awake! The Yanks showed grit; I like that. Baseballs got its magic, yknow? And Judge? Hes got that glint in his eye that says, Watch this, folks.
Man, Judges homer was like a shot of adrenaline! The Yankees dodged a bullet there. Its crazy how one swing can flip the script. Baseball, man, always keeping us on our toes.
Man, that Judge homer was like fireworks on the 4th of July! Explosive! The Yankees were on the ropes, then bam! Judge steps up like a hero. Thats the stuff baseball dreams are made of, aint it?
Man, Judges homer was like a shot of adrenaline! Reminds me of that time in 98 when Jeter went deep in the playoffs. Yankees got grit, no denying that! Gonna be epic to see how they roll on!
Man, Judges homer was like a shot of adrenaline to my baseball heart! The Yankees pulled off one heck of a comeback. Cant wait to see how this energy carries through the rest of the series!
Man, that Judge homer was like a lightning bolt in a storm! Talk about clutch. Yanks dodged a bullet there. Playoffs, man, you never know whats gonna happen next. Its the stuff that baseball dreams are made of!
Man, Judge really brought the heat with that homer! Reminds me of the good ol days of baseball, when a clutch play could turn the whole game around. Exciting stuff!
Man, when Judge hit that homer, I swear my heart skipped a beat! It was like watching history unfold right before my eyes. The Yankees really pulled a rabbit out of the hat with that one. Cant wait to see what happens next!
Man, that Judge homer was insane! Reminds me of the good ol days when baseball was full of surprises. Gotta give credit where its due, the Yankees really pulled through when it mattered most. Cant wait to see what happens next!
Yo, did you catch that Judge homer? Straight fire! That comeback had me on the edge, man. Yankees aint playin around. Whos next in the lineup to bring the heat? Lets go!
Man, Aaron Judges homer was like a bolt from the blue, totally turned the game around! Imagine the pressure in that at-bat. The Yankees clawed back and showed some serious grit. Thats playoff baseball for ya!
Man, that Judge bomb was pure electricity! The dude just flipped the script, no warning. I felt the tension from my couch, no lie. Yankees fought back hard, brought that heat. Playoffs, man, they never disappoint!